Myths Debunked on Cover Crops and Colder Soil Temperatures? – Final Report

Sometimes apparent myths prove to be true and sometimes they prove to be…myths

In March 2013 I asked my brother Don Robison from Robison Farms to help me figure out how cover crops might effect soil temperatures.  We have looked at data in previous posts trying to answer the question “Do Cover Crops that Survive the Winter Keep the Soil Colder in the Spring than Fall-Tilled Soil?”

Now I have asked Don to chart all of his data that he has taken since late March in fall-tilled soil, no-till soil, no-till soil with cover crop annual ryegrass, and a lawn.  Don added a test of taking moisture readings as well because “we know” that no-till soils are “always wetter and colder than fall-tilled soils.”  At least that is common “knowledge” from many farmers I talk to from Minnesota to Missouri and points eastward.

Don made some comments that I believe are helpful:

  • The soil type in the lawn is Miami silt loam, while the fields are Crosby silt loam.
  • The no-till w/o cover crop test had a compaction layer at ~3-9″ deep in this area in our compaction tests we conducted in 2012.  Don’s thought is that where he is doing the tests had a compaction layer closer to the 3″ depth (so there is less percolation).
  • Don reports “No conclusions yet and maybe there won’t be any, but an interesting trend I’m starting to see is that in this cool wet spring, the conventional tillage does not seem to be living up the reputation of being warmer and easier to till in the spring than no till.  That may very well change when the rainfall and temperatures become more like you would expect to see in the planting season.”

Data reveals that cover crops do not appear to be keeping the soil colder.

It appears that our no-till soils with cover crops has consistently been warmer or just as warm as the fall-tilled soils.  I am placing the charts below for you to observe the data.

Robison Farms Soil temperatures Spring 2013

 

 

 

 

 

Robison Farms Soil Moisture Sp 2013

 

 

 

 

 

Robison Farms Air Temperatures Sp 2013

 

 

 

 

 

Robison Farms Rainfall data Sp 2013

 

 

 

, , , , , , , ,

5 Responses to Myths Debunked on Cover Crops and Colder Soil Temperatures? – Final Report

  1. DCP May 21, 2013 at 7:26 pm #

    Interesting that the cover crops do not keep the soil colder in the spring….what about in the heat of the summer.

  2. Dave May 21, 2013 at 10:24 pm #

    During the summer the soil has shown to be cooler than the tilled or no-till soil w/o cover crops. A grad student at Purdue did some work on that last summer and verified that as well. Pretty awesome!

  3. Steve McGrew July 17, 2013 at 2:57 pm #

    How did you measure soil moisture. We used a microwave and scales, but it was very time consuming. We found the top two inches of soil had more moisture in the 26″ tall triticale of our neighbor’s compared to the soybean stubble without. Unfortunately the top 24″ of soil had less moisture in the tall triticale than the soybean stubble. I would guess if it had been killed, at some point even the top 24″ of soil would have had less moisture loss in the triticale.

  4. Dave July 28, 2013 at 10:23 pm #

    Steve, we used a moisture meter that meausred moisture in the top 4″ of soil.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Soil Health, Risk Management, and Wildlife: Observed Benefits of Cover Crops and No Till : Wildlife Promise - June 13, 2013

    […] field at 63 degrees. (Thanks to Dave Robison for first examining the soil temperature question: http://plantcovercrops.com/myths-debunked-on-cover-crops-and-colder-soil-temperatures-final-report/). Improved drainage has made all the difference.  And for me, no till and cover crops provide the […]

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.